The 11 Best Ricotta Substitutes You Probably Already Have in Your Fridge (Tested & Proven)

The 11 Best Ricotta Substitutes You Probably Already Have in Your Fridge (Tested & Proven)

If you use cheese as often as I do, you’ve probably hit a "Ricotta wall" at some point. Maybe you’re tired of that gritty texture, or perhaps you’re cooking for a vegan friend or someone cutting calories. Honestly, finding a solid substitute for ricotta cheese is way easier than you’d think.

Whether you're out of stock or just want to try something a bit "crazier" for your next lasagna, here are my top 11 alternatives that actually work.

1. Yogurt: The Mediterranean Twist

In many parts of the Middle East, yogurt is the go-to for sauces where we’d usually use Ricotta. It’s packed with potassium and B12, making it a much lighter, high-protein option.

Yogurt

Pro-Tip: Always use plain, unsweetened yogurt. The Greek-style stuff is best because it’s thicker. Just remember: once you bake it, those healthy probiotics won't survive the heat, so use it for flavor and texture, not just for the "good bacteria."

2. Béchamel Sauce: The French Mother Sauce

Back in the day, classic lasagna called for Béchamel, not Ricotta. It’s a simple mix of butter and flour (a roux) with milk. The best part? You have total control. Want it runnier? Add milk. Thicker? Dial it down. It holds up to long cooking times much better than cheese does.

Béchamel Sauce

3. Tofu: The Vegan Game-Changer

Don't roll your eyes at tofu! When mashed, the consistency is nearly identical to Ricotta. In a heavy dish like stuffed shells, the difference is almost negligible. It’s a blank canvas, mix in some fresh basil or nutritional yeast, and you’ll have a vegan filling that truly sings.

Tofu

4. Goat Cheese: For the Flavor Lovers

This is probably the closest match in terms of "mouthfeel." It’s a bit tangier and stronger than cow’s milk Ricotta, but it’s an almost perfect swap.

Goat Cheese

Just be careful, goat cheese melts faster, so keep an eye on it if you’re doing a long bake.

5. Whey (Ricottone): The "Upcycled" Choice

If you’ve ever made homemade mozzarella, don’t toss the leftover watery fluid (the whey). You can actually turn that whey back into a type of Ricotta called Ricottone. It’s a bit of a process, but it gives you fine control over the final density of your cheese.

Whey (Ricottone)

6. Cashews: A Vegan’s Best Secret

Hardcore vegans swear by soaked cashews. After an overnight soak and a quick spin in the food processor, they turn into a creamy, gritty paste that mimics Ricotta perfectly. It’s high in protein and surprisingly satisfying in baked ziti.

Cashews

7. Clabbered Milk: The Old-School Alternative

If you can’t get unpasteurized milk to make real clabber, don't worry. You can fake it by adding one tablespoon of lemon juice or vinegar to a cup of whole milk. It triggers a curdling process that creates a thick, sour-cream-like consistency that works wonders in savory recipes.

Clabbered Milk

8. Queso Fresco: The Creamy Crumbly Pick

Sometimes called "Queso Blanco," this Mexican staple is saltier and creamier than Ricotta. It breaks down into a runny state quickly, making it a fantastic choice for lasagna where you want a bit of "ooze," though it might be too messy for stuffed shells.

Queso Fresco

9. Crème Fraîche: The High-Fat Hero

If you aren't counting calories, Crème Fraîche is pure luxury. It’s less sour than sour cream and holds up beautifully under high heat. If you can't find it at the store, just mix a tablespoon of buttermilk into a cup of whole milk and let it sit for 12 hours.

Crème Fraîche

10. Parmesan: The Flavor Booster

On its own, Parmesan is too dry to replace Ricotta. However, it’s the ultimate "partner" cheese. Mix it with cottage cheese or even a bit of yogurt to dial back the grittiness and add that sharp, salty kick that everyone loves.

Parmesan

11. Mozzarella: The Italian Treasure

When all else fails, reach for the Mozzarella. It won't have that same grainy texture - it’s much stringier and clumpier, but it’s creamy and delicious. Avoid the pre-shredded stuff; go for fresh Mozzarella to get as close to that Ricotta "vibe" as possible.

Mozzarella

Final Thoughts

Ricotta is great, but it’s not the only player in the game. Whether you need a dairy-free swap like tofu or a gourmet upgrade like Crème Fraîche, these alternatives will save your dinner and maybe even make it better.

Which one are you trying first? Let me know in the comments below!

Back to blog

Leave a comment

Please note, comments need to be approved before they are published.

Related Posts